Everyone adds one secret ingredient to the cauldron. Lose a quick minigame round and you drink from the brew.
A communal punch bowl created by committee — which is exactly as dangerous and hilarious as it sounds. Each player secretly pours a shot measure of any liquid (liquor, mixer, juice) into a central cauldron. Quick minigame rounds decide who takes sips from the brew. The mixture grows increasingly chaotic as the night progresses because nobody tops it up with anything pleasant.
Place a large clear bowl or pitcher in the middle of the table (the cauldron) with a small shot glass for scooping. Everyone holds their personal drink alongside available mixers.
Going around the circle, each player secretly adds 1 shot-sized measure of any liquid to the cauldron with no explanation.
Once loaded, play a fast minigame round (e.g., highest drawn card, closest guess, first to blink).
The loser of the minigame scoops 1 full shot measure from the cauldron and drinks it.
After every third round played, each player adds 1 more secret measure to top up the cauldron.
Anyone who refuses to drink their assigned dose must immediately chug their entire personal drink.
When the cauldron is eventually emptied, the player who swallowed the final dose wins the game.
No player may reveal what ingredients they contributed until the cauldron is completely empty.
After drinking a shot from the cauldron, the drinker guesses 1 ingredient. If correct, the player who contributed that ingredient takes a sip of their own drink.
One player acts as the High Witch and brews the entire starting cauldron solo. Whenever a player drinks a shot after losing a minigame, the group votes on whether the brew is still drinkable. If the majority votes that it's undrinkable sabotage, the Witch must immediately take a shot from the cauldron alongside them!
Everyone looks down, then up at someone else. Eye contact is fatal — scream 'Medusa!' and down a shot.
Fifty years of audience callbacks, 'Time Warp' dancing, and virgin initiation — the rowdiest movie game ever created.
A bowl of sweets, one secretly marked or intensely sour. Eat, chew, and find out who takes the shot.
A row of shot glasses placed over secret tombstone epitaphs. Pick your grave and reveal your cause of death.